Q7What are the causes of non union according to the diamond concept?▸
Diamond concept: inductive, conductive, osteogenic, host and vascular factors
Mechanical instability: inadequate fixation, bone loss, poor bone quality
Inadequate vascularity: severe soft tissue injury with periosteal stripping, malalignment, bone loss, distraction
Poor bone contact: soft tissue interposition, malalignment, bone loss, distraction
Q8Describe the X-ray findings and postulated causes in this subtrochanteric non union.▸
Previous subtrochanteric fracture fixed with a long cephalomedullary device + 1 cerclage wire
No healing, bone defect, varus alignment, no broken implant
Atrophic non union
Biology: watershed area; mechanical: wide medullary canal, large deforming force; varus increases the bending moment, leading to increase in fracture strain per unit length; the region experiences the highest tensile stress according to Koch's diagram
Q9How is this subtrochanteric non union managed?▸
Deal with both the biological and mechanical problems
Exchange nail: larger nail provides more stability
Reaming provides bone graft
Q10How is non union assessed?▸
Rule out infection (initial open injury, wound infection, erythema/sinus, blood tests)
Delineate the cause: atrophic vs hypertrophic non union
Q13Describe the X-ray findings and management in the distal radius non union.▸
Fracture shaft of distal radius fixed with 6-hole DCP with compression
Positive callus, fracture gap still seen; need proper AP + lateral X-ray to delineate alignment; no ulnar fracture
One distal screw very near the fracture gap
Hypertrophic/oligotrophic non union
Management: rule out infection, delineate cause (initial malreduction, unstable fixation), whole forearm X-ray, revision plating + bone graft
Q14How are bone defects managed?▸
Further management depends on size of defect and integrity of soft tissue coverage, vascularity of tissue bed
Small <6cm: acute shortening, non-vascularised bone graft, Papineau technique
Intermediate up to 12cm: vascularised bone graft (e.g. fibular), can also provide soft tissue coverage in same flap
Large >6cm: acute shortening + distraction osteogenesis, bone transport, Masquelet technique
Amputation for significant bone/soft tissue/NV defect or patients unfit for multiple surgery
Q15Why is exchange nailing used for non union and what are the results?▸
Largest series by group in Edinburgh, published in 2016 BJJ: union 75% after 1st exchange, rising to 95% after 2nd exchange
In infected non union: 35% after 1st, 65% after second
Works by 3 mechanisms: larger nail improves mechanical stability; Reaming increases periosteal blood flow – stimulate the formation of periosteal new bone; reaming products are osteoinductive
Simple JBJS 2016: the strongest predictor of failure of exchange nailing was infection and suggested other treatment options such as ilizarov treatment should be preferred