FRCS Revision

This site is private

Enter the password to open the revision library.

Personal revision library · not clinical advice
FRCSRevision
Home / Bone and Joint / Bone grafts and synthetic substitutes
Bone and Joint

Bone grafts and synthetic substitutes

Autograft, allograft and xenograft biology, graft incorporation and synthetic bone substitutes

22 questions 2 source pages 2 fact-check flags

Images appear with the first question taken from each source page — tap a question to open it.

22 questions
Q1Define bone graft and the properties of an ideal graft.▸
  • Implanted materials to promote bone healing
  • Biological properties: osteoconduction, osteoinduction, osteogenesis, vascularity
  • Structural support
Q2What are the common uses of bone graft?▸
  • AJR - structural support (bone defect management)
  • Spine - induce fusion
  • Trauma - fracture nonunion
Q3How is a cancellous bone graft incorporated?▸
  • Inflammation phase: vascular ingrowth, chemotaxis
  • Revascularisation phase (0-3 weeks)
  • Creep substitution (3-12 weeks): angiogenesis, osteoblasts and osteoclasts introduced and work at the same time
  • Remodelling phase (>12 weeks)
  • Incorporation can be complete; no osteopenia during incorporation
Q4How is a cortical bone graft incorporated?▸
  • Initial incorporation at the host-graft junction by endochondral bone formation
  • Sequential action of osteoclast then osteoblast: graft bone removed by cutting cones then new bone laid down
  • 50% loss of strength in 3-6 months, then fully returns over 1-2 years
  • Incorporation is not complete; initial osteopenia on X-ray during bone absorption
  • Called reverse creep substitution
Q5Compare autograft with allograft.▸
  • Autograft pros: osteogenesis, no immunogenicity, less chance of infection
  • Autograft cons: limited supply, donor site morbidity
  • Allograft requires donor consent, screening, processing and storage
  • Aim of bone bank processing: decrease immune sensitisation and disease transmission
  • Other sources include synthetic bone substitute and xenograft
Q6What are the methods of allograft preservation?▸
  • Fresh frozen at -70deg: preserves BMP, better mechanical strength; immunogenic, disease transmission risk; shelf life 2 years at -20deg, 5 years at -70deg
  • Freeze dry (lyophilise): less immunogenic, less disease transmission, longer shelf life; weak structure, no BMP - purely osteoconductive
  • Fresh
Q7How are bone grafts classified?▸
  • By source: autograft / allograft / synthetic / xenograft
  • By structure: cortical or cancellous
Q8By what mechanisms are bone grafts incorporated into host bone?▸
  • Inflammation
  • Osteoblast differentiation
  • Osteoinduction and osteoconduction
  • Remodelling
Q9What factors affect bone graft uptake?▸
  • Biological: local vs systemic
  • Mechanical
  • Think of the factors affecting fracture healing
Q10What are the non-vascularised sources of autograft?▸
  • Femoral head
  • ASIS
  • PSIS
Q11Describe the ASIS autograft harvest and the structure at risk.▸
  • 2cm posterior to ASIS, 3cm wound along the crest
  • Subperiosteal elevation of iliacus
  • Lateral cutaneous nerve of thigh is at risk
Q12Describe the PSIS autograft harvest and the structures at risk.▸
  • 1cm lateral to PSIS, longitudinal incision
  • Subperiosteal elevation of gluteal muscle
  • Superior cluneal nerve L1-3 (6cm lateral to PSIS) at risk
  • Superior gluteal NV (6cm inferior to PSIS) at risk
Q13What are the vascularised sources of autograft?▸
  • Wrist: 1,2 intercompartmental supraretinacular (ICSR) bone graft for scaphoid; 4,5 ICSR bone graft for lunate AVN
  • Fibular
  • Iliac crest (deep iliac circumflex artery)
Q14How is a bone bank set up and allograft processed?▸
  • Donor consent and screening (IVDU, blood for HIV, Hep B/C, syphilis, Rhesus status)
  • Exclusion criteria: HIV, Hep B/C, malignancy, RA/autoimmune disease, steroid
  • Processing: physical debridement, ultrasonic processing (remove cells/blood), ethanol (denature protein), antibiotic soak, irradiation, +/- demineralisation
  • Then storage
Q15What is the principle of graft fixation - nail vs plate?▸
  • Nail > plate
  • Even stress distribution
  • Increased time for incorporation, needs a rigid device
  • Increase contact area
  • Never remove the implant
Q16What are the synthetic bone graft types?▸
  • Osteoconduction: tricalcium phosphate
  • Osteoinduction: bone morphogenic protein 2 and 7
  • Others: demineralised bone matrix, hydroxyapatite, calcium phosphate, calcium sulphate
Q17Describe tricalcium phosphate.▸
  • Ceramic scaffold providing a scaffold for ingrowth of vessels and osteogenic cells
  • Porosity 50% - balance between mechanical strength and porosity
  • Macropore 100-500mcg for ingrowth of vessels and cells
  • Micropore 10mcg increases surface area of remodelling
  • Available as blocks, wedges and granules; trade name Chronos (Synthes)
Q18What does DBM contain and not contain?▸
  • Contains: collagen, BMP, transforming growth factor-beta, residual calcium
  • Does NOT contain mesenchymal precursor cells
  • Made by acidic extraction of bone matrix from allograft, then sterilised (may decrease BMP availability)
  • Osteoconductive without structural support; minimally osteoinductive
  • Interproduct and interlot variability common
Q19How do bone morphogenic proteins work?▸
  • Osteoinductive; belong to the TGF-beta superfamily
  • Stimulate undifferentiated perivascular mesenchymal cells to differentiate into osteoblasts via serine-threonine kinase receptors
  • Activate intracellular signalling molecules called SMAD
  • rhBMP-2 and rhBMP-7 are FDA-approved for application in long bones and spine
  • BMP-2 marketed by Medtronic; BMP-7 by Stryker
Q20What are the contraindications to BMP?▸
  • Pregnancy
  • Allergy to bovine type I collagen
  • Infection
  • Tumor
  • Skeletal immaturity
Q21What are the complications of BMP?▸
  • Under- or overproduction of bone (heterotopic ossification)
  • Inflammatory responses / seroma formation
  • Not for cervical spine - increased cervical swelling
  • Early bone resorption
Q22How is DBM manufactured and what does the acidic extraction leave behind?▸
  • Acidic extraction of bone matrix from allograft removes the minerals
  • Leaves collagen, non-collagenous proteins and bone growth factors
  • BMP quantity is extremely low and variable
  • Sterilisation may decrease the availability of BMP

Fact check

rhBMP-2 and rhBMP-7 are FDA-approved for application in long bones and spine — outdated / imprecise — rhBMP-2 (INFUSE) is approved for anterior lumbar interbody fusion and acute open tibial shaft fractures; rhBMP-7 (OP-1) was approved via HDE only for recalcitrant long-bone nonunion and is no longer marketed in the US — source
Macropore 100-500mcg and micropore 10mcg increase remodelling surface area — unit error — pore sizes are measured in micrometres (um), not micrograms: macropores ~100-500um and micropores ~10um or less — source